Is Kubota Skid Steer Better Than Bobcat?

The compact skid steer loader market is a battleground, and two giants constantly vying for the top spot are Kubota and Bobcat. Choosing between these two brands can be a daunting task, as both offer robust machines with a wide range of capabilities. This article aims to provide a comprehensive comparison, digging deep into the features, performance, and overall value proposition of Kubota and Bobcat skid steers to help you make an informed decision.

Deciding which skid steer is "better" depends entirely on your specific needs and priorities. Factors like intended applications, budget, operator preferences, and dealer support all play crucial roles.

Kubota vs. Bobcat: A Detailed Comparison

Feature	Kubota Skid Steers	Bobcat Skid Steers
Engine	Kubota diesel engines, known for reliability and fuel efficiency, are standard. They often feature direct injection and meet stringent emissions standards. Kubota engines are generally considered to be simpler in design, potentially leading to easier maintenance in some cases. Kubota skid steers often have lower horsepower compared to similarly sized Bobcat models, but this can translate to better fuel economy.	Bobcat uses a variety of engines, including Bobcat-branded engines and engines from other manufacturers like Doosan. They focus on providing ample power for demanding applications. Bobcat often features more advanced engine technologies, such as turbocharging and electronic engine management systems, leading to higher horsepower and torque. Bobcat engines are generally more powerful, allowing for faster cycle times and better performance in heavy-duty applications.
Hydraulics	Kubota offers responsive hydraulic systems with good breakout force and lift capacity. They often feature auxiliary hydraulics for powering attachments. Kubota hydraulics are generally considered robust and reliable. Some models offer high-flow auxiliary hydraulics for specialized attachments. Kubota's hydraulic systems are often praised for their smooth operation and precise control.	Bobcat is known for its advanced hydraulic systems, offering excellent breakout force, lift capacity, and cycle times. Bobcat offers a wider range of hydraulic options, including standard flow, high flow, and even super flow systems for demanding attachments. Bobcat’s Advanced Attachment Control (AAC) system allows operators to customize hydraulic flow and pressure for optimal attachment performance. Bobcat hydraulic systems are often more complex, potentially requiring specialized knowledge for maintenance and repair.
Operating Capacity	Kubota offers a range of models with varying operating capacities, catering to different job requirements. Kubota's rated operating capacities are generally competitive within their respective size classes. Kubota skid steers are often designed with a focus on stability and balance, contributing to safe and efficient operation.	Bobcat offers a broad range of models with varying operating capacities, including some of the largest and most powerful skid steers on the market. Bobcat’s rated operating capacities are often higher than Kubota’s for comparable models. Bobcat’s larger models are capable of handling heavier loads and attachments, making them suitable for demanding applications like demolition and construction.
Lift Geometry	Kubota offers both radial and vertical lift models. Radial lift is suitable for digging and ground-level tasks, while vertical lift provides greater reach and lift height for loading trucks and handling pallets. The choice depends on the primary application. Kubota provides a good balance of reach and lift height depending on the chosen lift geometry.	Bobcat also offers both radial and vertical lift models. Bobcat's vertical lift models often boast higher lift heights and greater reach compared to Kubota's, making them ideal for applications requiring maximum vertical reach. Bobcat's radial lift models are known for their digging performance and stability.
Comfort & Controls	Kubota skid steers are designed with operator comfort in mind, featuring spacious cabs, ergonomic controls, and comfortable seating. Kubota often incorporates intuitive controls and easy-to-read displays. Some models offer features like air conditioning and adjustable suspension seats for enhanced operator comfort. The controls are generally straightforward and easy to learn, making Kubota skid steers user-friendly.	Bobcat is known for its advanced comfort and control features, including pressurized cabs, heated seats, and advanced control systems. Bobcat offers options like selectable joystick controls (SJC) that allow operators to customize the control layout to their preferences. Bobcat's control systems often provide more precise and responsive handling, enhancing operator productivity. Bobcat cabs are often more feature-rich, offering amenities like Bluetooth connectivity and rearview cameras.
Serviceability	Kubota skid steers are generally considered easy to service, with readily accessible components and straightforward maintenance procedures. Kubota often provides comprehensive service manuals and training materials to support maintenance efforts. Kubota's simpler engine design can contribute to easier and less expensive maintenance.	Bobcat skid steers can be more complex to service, requiring specialized tools and knowledge. Bobcat offers extensive dealer support and parts availability, but repairs can be more expensive due to the complexity of the machines. Bobcat’s advanced technology can require specialized diagnostic equipment for troubleshooting.
Price	Kubota skid steers typically have a lower initial purchase price compared to similarly equipped Bobcat models. This can make them an attractive option for budget-conscious buyers. Kubota's lower operating costs can also contribute to long-term savings.	Bobcat skid steers generally have a higher initial purchase price, reflecting their advanced features and higher performance capabilities. While the initial investment is higher, Bobcat's increased productivity and resale value can offset the cost over time.
Reliability	Kubota has a reputation for building reliable and durable machines. Many owners report long service lives with minimal downtime. Kubota's simpler design and robust components contribute to their overall reliability.	Bobcat also has a strong reputation for reliability, although their more complex systems can be prone to occasional issues. Bobcat’s extensive dealer network provides readily available support for repairs and maintenance. Bobcat's machines are generally built to withstand demanding conditions, but proper maintenance is crucial for ensuring long-term reliability.
Resale Value	Kubota skid steers generally hold their value well, but Bobcat often commands a higher resale price due to its brand recognition and reputation. Bobcat’s higher initial purchase price translates to a higher resale value, making them a good investment for some buyers.	Bobcat skid steers typically have excellent resale value, driven by their strong brand recognition, performance capabilities, and widespread demand. This can offset the higher initial purchase price.
Attachments	Kubota offers a wide range of attachments for its skid steers, allowing them to perform various tasks. Kubota attachments are generally well-built and durable. Kubota's attachment options are typically more focused on standard applications.	Bobcat offers the widest range of attachments in the industry, including specialized tools for specific applications. Bobcat attachments are known for their innovative design and high performance. Bobcat’s Advanced Attachment Control (AAC) system optimizes attachment performance.
Technology	Kubota skid steers offer essential features and technology for efficient operation. Kubota focuses on providing reliable and user-friendly technology.	Bobcat leads the way in technology, offering advanced features like remote operation, telematics, and automated machine functions. Bobcat’s technology is designed to enhance productivity, safety, and operator comfort.

Detailed Explanations

Engine: The engine is the heart of any skid steer. Kubota utilizes its own line of diesel engines, renowned for their reliability and fuel efficiency. Bobcat uses a mix of their own engines and those from other manufacturers, often prioritizing power output.

Hydraulics: Hydraulics are crucial for powering attachments and performing tasks like lifting and digging. Bobcat often boasts more advanced and powerful hydraulic systems, including high-flow options for demanding attachments.

Operating Capacity: This refers to the maximum weight the skid steer can safely lift. Bobcat generally offers models with higher operating capacities, making them suitable for heavier loads.

Lift Geometry: The lift geometry determines how the loader arms move. Radial lift is better for digging, while vertical lift excels at lifting and loading at higher heights. Both Kubota and Bobcat offer models with both types of lift geometry.

Comfort & Controls: Operator comfort is essential for productivity. Bobcat typically offers more advanced comfort features, such as pressurized cabs and heated seats, while Kubota focuses on ergonomic and user-friendly controls.

Serviceability: Ease of maintenance is crucial for minimizing downtime. Kubota skid steers are generally considered easier to service due to their simpler design.

Price: Kubota skid steers are typically more affordable than comparable Bobcat models, making them an attractive option for budget-conscious buyers.

Reliability: Both Kubota and Bobcat have strong reputations for reliability. Kubota's simpler design can contribute to fewer potential points of failure.

Resale Value: Bobcat skid steers typically hold their value better than Kubota models due to their strong brand recognition and demand.

Attachments: Bobcat offers a wider variety of attachments, including specialized tools for niche applications.

Technology: Bobcat often incorporates more advanced technology into its skid steers, such as remote operation and telematics systems.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which skid steer is more fuel-efficient? Kubota skid steers are generally considered more fuel-efficient due to their engine design and lower horsepower.

Which skid steer has a higher lift capacity? Bobcat skid steers typically offer higher lift capacities compared to similarly sized Kubota models.

Which skid steer is easier to service? Kubota skid steers are often easier to service due to their simpler design and readily accessible components.

Which skid steer has better resale value? Bobcat skid steers generally hold their value better than Kubota models.

Which skid steer has a wider range of attachments? Bobcat offers a significantly wider range of attachments, including specialized tools for various applications.

Conclusion

Choosing between a Kubota and a Bobcat skid steer is a matter of carefully weighing your specific needs and priorities. If you prioritize fuel efficiency, ease of maintenance, and a lower initial price, Kubota might be the better choice. If you need maximum power, advanced features, a wider range of attachments, and high resale value, Bobcat could be the ideal option. Thoroughly assess your requirements, compare specific models within your budget, and consider test-driving both brands before making a final decision.